#348---All-Star Game, 7/10/2007

 

The AL got all five of its runs on homers, the first coming from Ichiro Suzuki (who also collected two other hits to earn MVP laurels) on an inside the park homer into Pac Bell Park’s triples alley. Carl Crawford and Victor Martinez added homers later, and it was 5-2 AL heading into the ninth. JJ Putz retired the first two batters, but then the NL mounted a furious rally to try to avenge the AL’s two-out, bases empty ninth inning rally in the 2008 game. Dmitri Young got an infield single, Alfonso Soriano homered, and JJ Hardy walked to drive Putz from the game. K-Rod came in and promptly walked Derrek Lee and Orlando Hudson, but he got Aaron Rowand to fly to right to get the save by the skin of his teeth.

Playing in his last All-Star Game, Barry Bonds was 0-2, but at least he got to play in front of an appreciative home crowd rather than in front of the jackals that would have confronted him in any of the other 29 parks.

#347---All-Star Game, 7/11/2006

 

Vladimir Guerrero and David Wright traded second inning longballs before the NL took a 2-1 lead on Roy Halladay’s wild pitch in the third. For the next five innings, each side mustered only two baserunners as luminary relievers like Brian Fuentes and Derek Turnbow controlled the game.

In the ninth the actual relief luminaries came in. Trevor Hoffman (#2 on the all-time save list) got two comebackers and was just one out away before Paul Konerko singled and Troy Glaus doubled. Michael Young fouled off the first two pitches he saw, then lined a triple to center that pulled the game out of the fire for the AL.

Now it was Mariano Rivera’s (#1 on the all-time save list) chance, and he dodged a Jose Lopez error, to close out the NL.

#346---All-Star Game, 7/12/2005

 

It didn’t take long after “This Time it Counts” became a thing to go back to the model of the primary goal of the All-Star manager being to completely empty the bench and bullpen. The ninth inning is a perfect example as Bob Wickman, BJ Ryan, and Mariano Rivera were all deployed. The NL had the tying runs on with nobody out, but Paul LoDuca, Carlos Lee, and Morgan Ensberg could not deliver.

#345---All-Star Game, 7/13/2004

Roger Clemens did not have a good outing in his home park, as the AL batted around and put up six runs, hitting for the cycle with homers from Manny Ramirez and Alfonso Soriano. David Ortiz later replaced his teammate Ramirez and also hit a two-run homer; they each homered and walked, with Ramirez also making an out. Ted Lilly, Joe Nathan, Tom Gordon, Francisco Rodriguez, and Mariano Rivera combined to retire the final twelve NL hitters.

I think Dan Kolb and Ken Harvey win this game’s prize for most surprising All-Stars

#344---All-Star Game, 7/9/2002

 

This was the infamous All-Star tie that incited a ridiculous overreaction of “This Time it Counts” and a brief three-year period where the game was managed differently. Of course I’m obligated to point out Barry Bonds’ two-run homer in the third, after being robbed on the warning track by Torii Hunter in the first. The AL trailed 5-2 entering the seventh, but scored four to take the lead before the NL took it back in the bottom of the frame. Omar Vizquel’s eighth inning triple tied it up at seven, and from that point forward there was no further scoring, and after eleven innings it was decided that Freddy Garcia and Vicente Padilla not be hung out to dry. Bud Selig had quite a coup on his hands at his Milwaukee All-Star game.

#343---All-Star Game, 7/10/2001

 

The AL won this midsummer classic on the strength of three solo homers: back-to-back shots from Derek Jeter and Magglio Ordonez off Jon Lieber in the sixth, but most infamously Cal Ripken’s third inning homer off Chan Ho Park. Ripken celebration was the theme of the day, and my notes suggest that I wasn’t having it – the note at the very top bemoans the delay “before first pitch for Gwynn/Ripken waste of time”. Tony Gwynn did not play in this game, while Ripken was also feted by A-Rod moving him to shortstop for the first inning before they switched back to their appointed positions in the second.

Rookie Albert Pujols made his All-Star debut, entering at third base in the bottom of the fifth, drawing a walk in his only PA, and playing second base in the eighth inning. During the regular season, Pujols’ career at second base consisted of 3 1/3 innings in one 2008 game.

#342---All-Star Game, 7/11/2000

 

If you paid careful attention to last week’s scoresheet, you may note that 2000 marked the second time in three years that David Wells started the All-Star Game for the AL. In 1998, he was relieved by Roger Clemens, Brad Radke, and Bartolo Colon plus relievers; this time, he starting nod may be easier to grasp as he was relieved by James Baldwin, Aaron Sele, and Tim Hudson. Despite this unimpressive pitching staff, the AL bested the NL 6-3 in Atlanta when there wasn’t a bizarre civic religion that prevented such a thing. Derek Jeter was the star, going 3-3 and driving in the go-ahead runs (which stood up) off Al Leiter in the fourth.

#341---All-Star Game, 7/7/1998

 

I will be starting a series of sorts as I post all of the All-Star Game scoresheets I have, starting with the first I scored in 1998. I will not be revisiting 1999 (#103) or 2008 (#29), I missed 2003, and we all missed 2020. Otherwise I think I have an intact set. There are a couple good things about All-Star scoresheets. One is that keeping them proves that you are scorekeeping fanatic (although I suppose that having a vanity blog that posts scoresheets kept over almost thirty years already should suffice on that front). A second is that they are great snapshots of an era and a moment in time in the game, something that becomes more apparent with times than instead of being the names you think about every day as a baseball fan, names like Clemens and Maddux and Griffey and Piazza and Sheffield and McGwire leap off the page, and names like Erstad and Durham and O’Neill and Grieve and Kendall and Urbina now strike as more interesting in many ways than they were in the past, as some of them have become college coaches and others are reduced to an aging Mike Hargrove remembering only as the “little black guy from the White Sox” in a radio interview (Durham) and others have been jailed in tinpot dictatorships.

A few notables from this game, which in true ‘90s fashion was slugfest taken 13-8 by the junior circuit at that most ‘90s of ballparks, Coors Field:

* Roberto Alomar was the MVP, collecting a bunt hit in his first at bat, a homer later, another single, reaching on an error, and stealing two bases.

* Barry Bonds walked, flied out, then blasted a three-run homer off Bartolo Colon.

* Alex Rodriguez was voted in as the starter over Derek Jeter in this more enlightened time, homering in the fifth before Jeter replaced him.

* The AL stole six bases, the NL none. The AL

* Sammy Sosa did not appear in the game; I had to look up that he missed the game with a sore shoulder, at first wondering whether he had been left off the All-Star team as he chased Mark McGwire and Roger Maris.

* Jeff Shaw made his first appearance in a Dodger uniform in this game, as he had just been acquired from Cincinnati.

#340---KC @ CLE, 7/24/2020

 

This was Opening Day of the shortened season for these two teams, and Shane Bieber quickly served notice that 2020 was going to be his year. He shut out Kansas City for six innings allowing four hits and one walk with fourteen strikeouts. Three of the first four Royals reached base, but Adalberto Mondesi was caught stealing to short-circuit that potential rally. The Indians got the only runs Bieber would need in the fifth, and inning lead off by Jordan Luplow getting hit (of course). Each Indian reliever allowed a single baserunner in a single inning of walk, all on a free pass of some sort – two were hit batters as this game saw a whopping five.

#339---MIN @ CLE, 6/4/2019

 

On this night, the Bomba Squad was beaten at its own game. All seven runs scored on homers, but the Indians hit four to the Twins two. Marwin Gonzalez and Eddie Rosario both took Shane Bieber deep, but otherwise the Twins managed just three hits, one walk, and six strikeouts over Bieber’s seven innings of work.

For Cleveland, Francisco Lindor hit homers in consecutive at-bats in the third and fifth (he also walked and doubled), and Roberto Perez and Jake Bauers went back-to-back in the seventh.

#338---CLE @ MIN, 6/1/2018

 

Eduardo Escobar’s two homers powered the Twins to this 7-4 victory over the Indians. Eddie Rosario outwalked the Indians 2-1, which is never good sign; that they were both intentional walks, even less so; that the Tribe’s lone walk was drawn by Francisco Lindor to lead off the game, not particularly relevant.

#337---CLE @ BAL, 6/19/2017

 

The Indians bludgeoned the Orioles pitching staff, with some of the standout offensive performers being Jose Ramirez (3-6, 2 doubles, 1 triple); Carlos Santana (2-2, HR, 2 walks, SF); and Austin Jackson (2-4, 2 doubles, 1 walk, 3 RBI). Each accounted for almost more offense that Corey Kluber yielded to Baltimore in a brilliant complete game shutout (three hits – all two-out singles, no walks, eleven strikeouts, 108 pitches, no runners reaching second base). And he finished with a flourish, striking out the side in the ninth.

#336---TB @ CLE, 6/22/2016

The Indians jumped right on Chris Archer with a walk and Jason Kipnis homer to lead off the game, and that would have been enough for Trevor Bauer in this game I attended on the day of the Cavaliers championship parade. He went the distance, allowing one run on three hits, one walk, and ten strikeouts. Tampa Bay’s only run came on Corey Dickerson’s two-out infield single in the sixth, on which Logan Morrison overran the bag at third and was tagged for the third out (“OVR65” on the scoresheet).

One of my lasting memories of the day was the inebriated man waiting to get on the rapid after the game, flush with euphoria over the Cavs’ victory, who kept shouting “Indians over the Cubs in seven”. So close yet so far. 

#335---CLE @ KC, 6/2/2015

 

The 2015 Royals, en route to the World Series title, were famed for their weak rotation and lockdown bullpen. But on this night, the roles were reversed and the Indians came away with a 2-1 victory. Both starters pitched well: Carlos Carrasco went seven, allowing one run on five hits, two walks, and eight strikeouts. Jeremie Guthrie threw one more pitch than Carrasco, but it only carried him through 5 2/3 in which he allowed one run on just two hits (Brandon Moss’ homer provided the run, and Carlos Santana’s double drove him from the contest), one walk, and one strikeout.

Kelvin Hererra fanned three Indians in the seventh, but in the eighth Wade Davis issued two walks and a two-out single to Michael Brantley. Meanwhile, Indians pitchers retired the last seventeen Royals in order. The eighth inning, facing the Royals most dangerous hitters, was a now obsolete masterclass by Terry Francona in milking the platoon advantage to the maximum possible extent: lefty Nick Hagadone to get Mike Moustakas, righty Bryan Shaw to get Lorenzo Cain, lefty Marc Rzepczynski to get Eric Hosmer. Three batters, three pitchers, three outs, never to be seen again.

#334---CLE @ TEX, 6/6/2014

 

The Rangers jumped on Trevor Bauer for four runs in the second, but a three-run homer from Lonnie Chisenhall and a solo blast from Asdrubal Cabrera pulled it even in the fourth, and it would stay that way into the seventh. Michael Choice hit the first pitch he saw from Marc Rzepczynski for a homer, and Texas tacked one on in the eighth for the final margin. Outside of the two homers, Yu Darvish was able to dodge the nine hits and three walks he allowed while fanning eight over seven innings.

Scoring note: in the fifth, Shin-Soo Choo made the third out at home trying to score on a would-be wild pitch, which I mark as “OA21” (for “out advancing”, which covers any time a runner is out attempting to voluntarily advance).

#333---TB @ CLE, 6/1/2013

 

This game would be very important in the final standings as Cleveland, Tampa Bay, and Texas went down the wire in the AL Wildcard race, but in the moment it was notable as a clean Ubaldo Jimenez start. It got off to an inauspicious start as he walked Matt Joyce to lead off the game, but that would be the only walk he allowed as he shut out the Rays for eight innings on four hits with seven strikeouts in a tidy 108 pitches. His counterpart Chris Archer was touched for two-run homers by Jason Giambi and Asdrubal Cabrera.

#332---MIN @ CLE, 6/1/2012

 

The Indians battered Carl Pavano for seven runs in 3 2/3 innings, with a Lonnie Chisenhall two-run shot and a Jason Kipnis grand slam as the big blows. This happened to be the last really good start of Derek Lowe’s career – he had four subsequent starts that officially qualified as “quality starts”, but they were all of the 6 IP/3 R variety (well, one was 6.2/3). He struck out just two and walked one, pitching to contact. After this game he had a 3.06 ERA which would balloon to 5.52 by July 31, after which he was traded to the Yankees and worked exclusively out of the bullpen for the rest of the season and all of 2013.

Leading off the fifth, Anthony Swarzak tagged the bag to record an unassisted putout of Casey Kotchman – not a particularly rare play, but one worth noting on a scorekeeping blog when it pops up organically.